Formal validity of all resolutions adopted by the general meeting of a non-listed stock corporation

On 16 April 2014, the Higher Regional Court of Jena (case no. 2 U 608/13) held that all resolutions adopted at a general meeting are invalid if even a single resolution fails to comply with the formal requirements of section 130(1) sentence 1 AktG.

The defendant is not listed on the stock exchange. In addition to other resolutions, the company’s general meeting adopted an amendment to the articles of association. This amendment was notarised, while the remaining resolutions were only recorded in minutes in private written form. The claimant is a shareholder and seeks a declaration that all resolutions adopted at the general meeting are invalid. In the view of the Higher Regional Court of Jena, all resolutions are invalid under section 241 nos. 2 and 3 AktG because, pursuant to section 130(1) sentence 1 AktG, all resolutions should have been notarised.

Under section 130(1) sentence 1 AktG, all resolutions of the general meeting must be notarised. Section 130(1) sentence 3 AktG provides an exception for non-listed companies (“small AG”):

“In the case of non-listed companies, minutes signed by the chairperson of the supervisory board are sufficient, provided that no resolutions are adopted for which the law requires a three-quarters majority or a larger majority.”
Under section 179(1) sentence 1 and section 179(2) sentence 1 AktG, every amendment to the articles of association requires a three-quarters majority.

The Higher Regional Court of Jena bases its reasoning on the wording of section 130(5) AktG. Section 130(5) AktG provides that, immediately after the meeting, the management board must submit a publicly certified copy to the commercial register. In the case of a non-listed company — the case covered by section 130(1) sentence 3 AktG — a signed copy by the chairperson of the supervisory board is sufficient. In the present case, however, only the amendment to the articles of association had been notarised. Moreover, splitting the entire meeting into parts would be nonsensical. The general meeting constitutes a self-contained factual process which must either be notarised in its entirety or signed in private written form.

Practical note: The management board is advised to consider, for each resolution, whether the formal requirements of section 130(1) sentence 1 AktG have been complied with. Otherwise, all resolutions may be subject to challenge.
Drafting tip: Section 130(1) sentence 3 AktG is always inapplicable where a three-quarters majority is required by law. However, an entrepreneur is not prevented from agreeing a three-quarters majority in the articles of association. The wording of section 130(1) sentence 1 AktG does not apply precisely to this kind of majority.
In this context, the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe (9 October 2013, case no. 7 U 33/13) held that the chairperson of the general meeting is also entitled to sign the minutes, even if he or she is not the chairperson of the supervisory board.

Linked Practice Areas

Ready to discuss your matter?

Send us a message and we’ll route it to the right team.